top of page
Search

Silent Friend

Oct 5
3 min read

Released 2025. Director: Ildiko Enyedi



SILENT FRIEND IS A GIFT FOR BOTANISTS, visual artists and film lovers who luxuriate in meditative cinema. Hungarian writer-director Ildiko Enyedi graft three unrelated stories loosely in a way that immediately recalls Terrence Malick. The film is mesmerising and striking in places, while leaving the connective tissues between the triptych rather flimsy.

In the early 1900s, Grete (Luna Wedler) becomes one of the first women admitted to Germany's Marburg University after a panel of chauvinistic professors determined to humiliate her are won over by the young woman's knowledge and poise under pressure. Grete delves deeper into her study of botany when she takes up photography and uses the camera to enhance her research.

In the 1970s, Hannes (Enzo Brumm) is smitten with fellow student Gundula who entrusts him to look after her project while she's away. Hannes fiddles with Gundula's geranium plant pegged to a sensor and discovers the flower's surprising reaction to its environment. In almost a sci-fi revelation, Hannes teaches the geranium to open the garden gate whenever he comes near. (And people think I'm mad talking to my house plants.)

In 2020, visiting neuroscientist Professor Tony Wong (Tony Leung Chiu-Wai) is the sole resident in his university lodging during the COVID shutdown. He sets up an unconventional experiment using an old tree as his subject by measuring electrical activity similar to capturing brainwaves, only to be sabotaged by a hostile caretaker.

In these three stories unfolding across three timelines, the only constant is the presence of a ginkgo biloba tree, which we see at the start of the movie as a seed germinating in the mid 1880s, becoming a towering entity over the passage of time amidst changes in social attitudes and advancements in science. Enyedi makes the tree a physical signpost, a sentinel of nature alongside an evolution of human pursuits to understand the mysteries of the natural world.

Gergely Palos' cinematography is captivating, using stunning close-ups, time-lapse and a vibrancy that not only emphasises the life in plants, specifically the ginkgo biloba, but even suggests these plants are sentient. Some of the shots, whether they are photographed on a cellular level or CGI, are truly magnificent. As Grete sits under the giant tree smoking a cigarette, the wisps of smoke is breathed in by the cells of the leaves above her.

Sporadic moments in the three stories come alive, such as when Hannes discovers what the geranium is capable of, Grete responses stoically to the grilling by the admissions committee, and the frosty caretaker warms to Tony's gracious temperament. On the whole, however, the movie feels like a free-flowing stream and the tree a hazy marker and vaguely circumstantial to the plot's picaresque nature.

Silent Friend is more a presentation of arthouse sensibility than mainstream narrative. Whatever it's attempting to say about the three characters, the insights are thin and do not coalesce into a unified statement about the human condition or a grand philosophical vision.

As we slip in and out of the three stories which do not really have proper beginnings and endings, the final idea that remains is the majesty of nature, as emblematic by the ginkgo tree. Through the seasons and years, the trunk widens, its cracked and gnarly bark ages; the canopy expands, its foliage of fan-shaped leaves turn from green to golden. The slowly retreating concluding shot gives us a stunning view of how magnificent the tree is, and the lives and pursuits that have swirled around this watch tower of history are dwarfed by its deep-rooted majesty.


Click image above to view trailer. New window will open.

 
 
 

4 Comments


Ruth Maramis
Ruth Maramis
Oct 10

I missed this last year, though my friend who saw it at TIFF loved it. "A gift for botanist, visual artists and film lovers who luxuriate in meditative cinema." It sounds like something I'd enjoy!!

Like
lifeinthedark.film
Oct 13
Replying to

Hey Ruth, let's hope this will be available on Mubi soon, for everyone who missed it at the cinemas.

Like

stevekingpersonal
Oct 07

This is a strange little movie, it took a bit to get into, but once I did, it really drew me in.

Like
lifeinthedark.film
Oct 13
Replying to

Some viewers found this movie challenging because of its slow pacing and unconventional storytelling. On the other hand, those who enjoyed it really connected with the message and approach.

Like

Join my mailing list

© 2019-2026 by Patrick Kok. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page